Re: [DMCForum] Planar?
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [DMCForum] Planar?
- From: Martin Gutkowski <martin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 26 May 2004 01:35:12 +0100
Sounds very similar to the Quad ESL's (electrostatic loudspeakers), of
which I have one (my dad's old ESL57, and a Quad 2 if anyone want to
> On Tue, 25 May 2004, Farrar Hudkins wrote:
> > Er, pardon me for showing my ignorance, but ... The only "planar" I'm
> > familiar with is planar geometry.
> You're on the right track. Planar speakers, also called ribbon or
> quasi-ribbon speakers (two subtly different varieties), are speakers which
> use a thin vibrating sheet to create sound instead of a vibrating cone.
> Essentially, they consist of a tightly stretched membrane suspended in
> between mangets. The membrane is either made of plastic (often mylar)
> with wires running through it or is one large membrane conductor. As the
> amplified signal passes through the membrane, the EM interaction between
> the membrane and the magnets causes the entire plane to vibrate, producing
> the desired sound across the whole surface.
> Where cone speakers have a definite center to the sound, and thus can
> sometimes give away the fact that they're speakers, not live sound, planar
> speakers produce the sound over the entire surface of the speaker and can
> produce a hauntingly realistic soundstage. They tend to be a bit more
> finicky about placement, and are generally good only for small listening
> environments (i.e. home audio room, not a dance hall), but in the right
> environment they sound simply phenomenal. Cones cannot compare.
> Because of the design of planars, they are very thin. My main speakers,
> Magnepan MG1.6s, have faces 19"x65", but are only 2" thick. Planars don't
> need cabinets to sound right, hence my initial jab at you.
> Really the only downside of planars is they have a hard time with low end,
> so it's essential they be paired with an appropriate subwoofer to generate
> a good flat response.
> Magnepan is probably te most well known planar speaker manufacturer in the
> world. You can check out their site at www.magnepan.com.
|Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
Yahoo! Groups Links
Back to the Home of PROJECT VIXEN